Barnaba da Modena
As my project is on Barnaba's banner for the Confraternity of St Anthony, this page is probably more interesting to me than anyone else. Its main function is to sort out what our hero did, when, and where; having made the cardinal error of failing to be included by Vasari in his Lives, Barnaba has managed to remain less documented than his more fortunate, but in some cases less illustrious, Tuscan contemporaries.
The 'when' is a problem; Barnaba was in the habit of signing and dating his works, which helps; however, this does not apply to all the works that remain to us and their chronology is often a matter of some conjecture.
Most of the works in Liguria, Piedmont and Emilia I saw, or at least established their whereabouts, in May 2002 on a trip to Italy. For other works I have relied on the usual sources. This list is far from comprehensive; if anyone can supply an image for the missing ones, or can add details and corrections, I would be very grateful.
Barnaba da Modena was active in Genoa (Liguria) from about 1353 to about 1383. These years marked the high point of Genoa's power in the 14th century - rivalled only by Venice, the Genoese fleet controlled Mediterranean trade, though the city was still riven by factional rivalry.
Although a native of Modena (Emilia), he was first recorded as a Genoese citizen in 1363 - after the required ten years residency - hiring Tuscan assistants in 1361 and 1362. He was paid for paintings (now lost) for the Palazzo Ducale, Genoa, in 1364 and restored a panel for the Genoese Loggia de' Banchi in 1370.
His earliest certain painting is the damaged polyptych of the Virgin and Child with Saints, signed, unlike later works, in capital letters.
He was invited to Pisa in 1380 to complete the fresco cycle by Andrea da Firenze depicting scenes from the Life of St Ranieri in the Camposanto. Although it seems unlikely that he carried out this work (which was completed by Antonio Veneziano some years later), he evidently went to Pisa around this time.
Barnaba witnessed the sale of a house in Modena in 1380 but had returned to Genoa by 1383. Commissions are also recorded in Sicily both for Barnaba and his follower Nicolò da Voltri, who perpetuated Barnaba's imagery and much of his style in Liguria into the 15th century.
top
Works in London and the United Kingdom
click to enlarge
The Coronation of the Virgin; The Trinity; The Virgin and Child; The Crucifixion
1374
National Gallery, London
This may have once formed two wings of a diptych. The donors are Juana Manuel (1335-­81) and her father Don Juan Manuel. Barnaba painted two large altarpieces which were sent to the Manuel Chapel in Murcia Cathedral.
The panels are:
  • Top left: the Coronation of the Virgin
  • Top right: the Trinity with Christ on the cross supported by God the Father, and the Holy Ghost as a dove; at the corners of the cross the symbols of the evangelists; the Virgin and Saint John are at the foot of the cross
  • Bottom left: the Virgin and Child with Saint Raphael presenting the two donors
  • Bottom right: the Crucifixion with angels carrying off the soul of the good thief and devils that of the bad thief, the Magdalen, the fainting Virgin attended by the Holy Women and Saint John
  • The predella: the twelve apostles
click to enlarge
Pentecost
National Gallery, London
The Virgin Mary and the twelve apostles are gathered together sometime after Christ’s Ascension into Heaven. They are shown with their hands joined in prayer, and they receive the Holy Spirit, which descends as a dove and grants them the power to speak 'in tongues'. New Testament (Acts 2: 1­4).
The work was probably part of a composite picture, which may have included an Ascension (Rome, Pinacoteca Capitolina).
A Nativity and a Flight into Egypt (both Bologna) have also been associated with these two pictures, but the connection appears unlikely as the Bolognese pictures are significantly smaller.
click to enlarge
Madonna and Child
c. 1975
Courtauld Institute
This tiny (19.1 x 26.5 cm) work has a striking intimacy.
The wriggling Christ child grasps his mother's mantle with one hand and a scroll bearing a text from the Sermon on the Mount ('Blessed are the Pure in Heart') in the other.
click to enlarge
Banner of the Genoese Confraternity of St Anthony
1372(?)
Victoria and Albert Museum
Tempera on canvas - a very rare survival because of its extreme fragility. It is in remarkably good repair.
Seated on the left is St Anthony Abbot with his tau cross and bell. On the right is St Eligius, patron saint of blacksmiths. He holds a horse's leg and a blacksmith's butteris - the saint shod a recalcitrant horse, possessed by the devil, by cutting off its leg, shoeing it, and then joining it on again.
Kneeling before them are diminutive devotees in the white, backless robes of a flagellant confraternity. The composition is similar to the St Catherine in Milan.
The Confraternity of St Anthony Abbot, documented in 1232, was one of the oldest in Genoa.
On the reverse (the work is under glass, hence the rather unfortunate reflection), Mary and St John the Evangelist mourn, while St Anthony kneels at the foot of the Cross.
The banner has a border of roundels containing saints on one side and prophets on the other.
no image available
Nativity
Saltwood Castle, Kent
Clark Collection
top